The Indian government has filed court documents accusing Xiaomi of failing to disclose royalty agreements with technology partners, potentially exposing the company to more than $150 million in back taxes. According to The Hindu BusinessLine, the dispute centers on whether payments made to intellectual property holders should be included in the customs value of imported components. The government argues that Xiaomi and its former contract manufacturer, Flex, did not fully reveal these financial arrangements until investigators intervened.
The case serves as a critical test for how India regulates the relationship between original equipment manufacturers and their contract partners. The government’s filing, reported for the first time by Reuters, states that Xiaomi knew the licensing arrangements but withheld them. The authorities are seeking the recovery of unpaid taxes and penalties, asserting that the company provided the relevant agreements only after the investigation had already begun. Xiaomi holds approximately 12% of the Indian smartphone market and is currently facing multiple regulatory hurdles, including a proposed probe by the Serious Fraud Investigation Office into its business model.
Xiaomi’s legal challenge, filed in January, seeks to overturn a tribunal ruling that found the company underpaid duties in the three years prior to 2020. The smartphone maker argues that its royalty payments, which range from 2% to 5%, are separate from the value of the physical components imported by contract manufacturers and should not attract tariffs. The company contends that the tribunal’s decision reflects an industry-wide mistrust of standard manufacturing practices. The Indian government has asked the Supreme Court to dismiss this challenge, maintaining that the failure to disclose the contractual structure was a deliberate omission.
The dispute also involves Flex, which is urging the court to quash the tribunal’s view that it willingly participated in layering transactions to undervalue imports. The government is seeking to throw out this challenge as well, stating that Flex is liable for not placing the underlying contracts before customs authorities. The Hindu BusinessLine notes that a win for Indian authorities could lead to similar scrutiny in other sectors such as pharmaceuticals and autos. The government clarified that its case does not suggest all contract manufacturing is impermissible, but rather focuses on specific failures in valuation disclosure.