A review published in Frontline by critic Prathyush Parasuraman argues that Namit Malhotra’s Ramayana: Part 1, directed by Nitesh Tiwari, is defined by a pervasive fear of offending religious sentiments. The article posits that this caution props up the moral spine of the protagonist, Rama, played by Ranbir Kapoor, while allowing the antagonist Ravana, portrayed by Yash, to emerge as a charismatic anti-hero. The review describes this dynamic as an "unintended subversion" of the traditional hero-villain template, transforming the film into a dual-hero narrative where the villain’s charm overshadows the hero’s rigidity.

According to the report, the film’s authorship is heavily deferred to its producer, who has claimed creative control over the Rs. 4,000-crore budget. The review suggests that this deference to an imagined, fiercely religious audience has resulted in a narrative that avoids challenging their beliefs. The article notes that this fear extends to the portrayal of Sita, played by Sai Pallavi. Although the character is established as a warrior, the film refuses to depict her fighting back when kidnapped, likely to avoid showing Ravana touching her. This decision, the review argues, leaves the character caught between feminism and faith, causing her agency to collapse.

The critique highlights specific narrative choices that flatten Rama’s complexity. In the Surpanakha episode, the film omits Rama’s role in ordering her mutilation, instead showing him silent while Lakshmana acts. The review questions whether this silence indicates shame or a failure to recognize his wife in disguise, noting that the film quickly dismisses these provocative questions by having Sita berate Lakshmana. By axing Ravana’s lust for Sita and focusing solely on his revenge for his sister’s mutilation, the film makes the kidnapping more morally acceptable but reduces the villain’s depth.

The article contrasts this approach with the literary Ramayana, where Rama struggles with his identity as a god among men. It cites scholar Arshia Sattar’s essays to argue that the film misses an opportunity to explore Rama’s anguish by keeping him in a straitjacketed moral framework. The review concludes that the film’s climax, where Rama breaks down and weeps, is the only moment that makes him palpable, as it reveals the human beneath the divine reputation. The piece suggests that the film’s caution ultimately breeds curiosity about what has been sidestepped, leaving the audience to inhabit the gaps in the narrative.