Telecom experts and cybersecurity researchers have raised serious technical objections to the Department of Telecommunications’ (DoT) mandate requiring messaging platforms to verify SIM cards. The directive, originally issued in November 2025, is scheduled to take effect in January 2027, following a deadline extension to December 31, 2026. According to MediaNama, the rule targets telecommunication identifier user entities (TIUEs), which include apps like WhatsApp and Telegram that use mobile numbers for user identification. The core contention is that the proposed verification methods cannot reliably confirm whether a user’s subscription is active, only whether the SIM card is physically inserted in the device.

During an online discussion on November 13, 2026, Parag Kar, an independent telecom consultant, explained that applications can verify a SIM in three ways. The first involves asking the phone’s operating system if the registered SIM is present. This method works without cellular signal but cannot confirm if the operator has deactivated the line. The other two methods require network connectivity: querying the telecom operator via the GSMA CAMARA interface or sending an SMS. Kar noted that for users relying exclusively on Wi-Fi, only the operating system check is viable, leaving apps unable to detect if a SIM has been cancelled by the provider.

Suman Kar, chief executive of Banbreach, emphasized that SIM presence is not equivalent to an active subscription. He argued that the distinction is critical for security and functionality. Meghna Bal, founder of the Esya Centre, highlighted that many users in areas with poor cellular coverage depend entirely on Wi-Fi. She stated that she is in an area of Delhi where she gets no signal in her house, making her pretty dependent on Wi-Fi for external communication. If apps enforce strict SIM binding, these users could lose access to essential communication tools.

The mandate also threatens business operations. Bal warned that businesses using a single number for multiple employees or those relying on APIs for customer service would face disruptions. Suman Kar added that customer relationship management systems linked to WhatsApp could fail, impacting contract fulfillment. Parag Kar questioned how small business owners using desktop-based WhatsApp would manage transactions away from their registered phones. He cautioned that without involving telecom operators to distinguish genuine travelers from fraudsters, the rules could create significant operational risks. The debate continues as the implementation deadline approaches.