The Telangana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (TSCDRC) has ruled that a Unified Payments Interface (UPI) PIN does not, by itself, prove that a customer authorized a transaction. In an order passed on November 10, a bench comprising Commission President Mamidi Christopher, S Sandhya Rani, and K Venkateswarlu directed the State Bank of India (SBI) to refund Rs 55,000 to a 44-year-old woman. The commission also ordered the bank to pay Rs 30,000 in compensation and litigation costs. According to MediaNama, the bench held that authentication mechanisms alone cannot establish customer consent without concrete evidence of agreement.

The dispute began on November 3, 2022, when Rs 55,000 was debited from the woman’s account. She stated she did not make the payment or share credentials. SBI rejected her claim, arguing that the transaction passed mobile and SIM-binding checks using her PIN, implying she authorized it. The commission rejected this defense, noting SBI failed to provide evidence that the woman made the transaction or shared her information. MediaNama reported that the commission held that authentication alone does not prove consent, distinguishing between technical verification and actual user agreement.

SBI also argued that the customer delayed reporting the fraud. The commission excluded Sundays from the calculation and determined that the woman had reported the incident within the required three-working-day window. She filed a complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal on November 6 and 7, 2022, and submitted a written complaint at her SBI branch. Despite acknowledging the complaint, the bank did not refund the amount. Consequently, the commission found SBI guilty of a deficiency in service for failing to address the grievance properly and comply with prescribed security standards.

This ruling aligns with the Reserve Bank of India’s (RBI) 2017 guidelines, which place the burden of proof on banks to demonstrate customer negligence in cases of third-party fraud reported within three working days. The commission’s decision reinforces that banks must carry the loss if they cannot prove the customer was negligent. The case highlights the evolving legal landscape surrounding digital payments in India, contrasting with other judicial interpretations that have treated user actions like clicking suspicious links as negligence. The RBI is set to revise these rules effective January 1, 2027, extending the reporting window to five calendar days.