A recent analysis by Daily Maverick highlights the significant tax disadvantages faced by South African family trusts holding inherited assets. Kenny Meiring, an independent financial adviser, explains that while trusts offer wealth protection, their tax treatment can be punitive compared to individual ownership. The report details how current regulations impose a flat 45% income tax rate on trusts, which drastically increases the effective capital gains tax burden on investment profits.

When a trust sells an investment at a profit, 80% of that gain is included in its taxable income. At the 45% tax rate, this results in an effective capital gains tax rate of 36%. In contrast, individuals include only 40% of capital gains in taxable income, leading to a maximum effective rate of 18%. This disparity means a trust can pay twice as much tax as an individual in the highest bracket. Meiring notes that while there is an exception allowing gains to be vested in resident beneficiaries, this must be done in strict compliance with tax rules.

The report examines the dilemma of whether to distribute an inheritance immediately or retain it within the trust. Distributing funds to beneficiaries reduces future investment taxes but exposes assets to estate duty and removes the protective benefits of the trust structure. Assets in a discretionary trust generally fall outside the personal estates of beneficiaries without vested ownership, preserving family wealth across generations. Meiring warns that losing this structure could increase estate duty exposure and reduce flexibility.

To mitigate these costs, the article proposes using a sinking fund, an investment structure offered by life insurance companies. Unlike standard endowments, sinking funds have no life assured, making them suitable for trusts. The tax rate for a sinking fund is 30%, with capital gains taxed at an effective rate of 12%. This rate is one-third of the 36% paid by trusts on direct investments. For example, on a R5-million gain, a sinking fund could save R1.2-million compared to direct trust investment.

Meiring advises caution against restructuring existing portfolios with unrealised gains, as selling them to move funds into a sinking fund could trigger a large tax liability. Instead, he recommends retaining current investments and using the inheritance to establish a new, tax-efficient portfolio. This approach avoids crystallising existing gains while improving the tax efficiency of future growth.