The death of a young otter found struggling in untreated sewage at Cape Recife has reignited concerns over Nelson Mandela Bay’s crumbling infrastructure. Bay wildlife expert Arnold Slabbert is considering laying criminal charges against the municipality and individual officials for allegedly flouting environmental laws. The incident occurred after Professor Lorien Pichegru alerted Slabbert to the fragile animal in what he described as a “sea of sewage”.

An autopsy revealed the otter’s stomach was severely scarred, resembling acid damage. Slabbert stated that the water was toxic and rotten, warning that continued discharge creates dead zones where marine life cannot survive. He noted that the municipality lacks the capacity and desire to manage wastewater systems effectively, with most facilities pushing sewage directly into the sea without enforcement.

Slabbert collected water samples alongside police and Professor Nadine Strydom from Nelson Mandela University. Strydom described the smell at the beach as unreal, comparing it to a powerful ammonia scent. She emphasized that properly treated wastewater should never smell that way. The samples have been sent to an independent laboratory for testing, with results pending before any legal action proceeds.

The Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment confirmed two ongoing criminal investigations into the municipality. One concerns sewage spills between April 2024 and November 2025, while another relates to 2022 harbor pollution referred to the National Prosecuting Authority. The South African Human Rights Commission also found evidence of widespread pollution, threatening residents’ constitutional rights to a healthy environment.

Dr. Gary Koekemoer of the Wildlife and Environment Society of South Africa described the crisis as systemic. He noted that oyster farms regularly suspend production due to contamination failing international standards. Koekemoer attributed the collapse partly to vandalism but largely to neglected maintenance and poor planning. He highlighted the municipality’s Green Drop assessment score of 36.3%, the lowest ever recorded, indicating regression rather than progress.

Koekemoer argued that political instability, including frequent mayoral changes, has diverted attention from infrastructure needs. He called for a permanent city manager to restore stability and address the sanitation crisis. The Nelson Mandela Bay Municipality acknowledged a request for comment but had not responded by publication time.