The Supreme Court has reserved its judgment in the All India Judges Association case regarding the enhancement of the superannuation age for district judges to 62 years. A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana directed the Attorney General, R Venkataramani, to make a final attempt to persuade states and union territories that continue to oppose the increase. The Court has granted these authorities two weeks to revisit the issue before the judgment is delivered.
During the proceedings, the Court addressed the primary objections raised by several states, which cited additional financial burdens, discontent among other government employees, and the impact on young judicial entrants. The bench had previously dismissed the financial burden argument, noting that retaining senior judges defers the payment of pensions and retiral dues, thereby reducing immediate fiscal pressure. Justice Bagchi remarked that paying pensions without work while hiring new incumbents creates a greater burden, stating, "And secondly is legitimate expectation of the cadre," according to LiveLaw. The Court emphasized that judicial officers enter service at an advanced age, distinguishing their service conditions from those of civil servants.
LiveLaw reported that while 15 states and union territories now support the enhancement, 12 continue to oppose it, and four, including Gujarat and Delhi, have sought more time. The opposing states include Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Bihar, and Haryana. Senior Advocate Siddharth Bhatnagar, appearing as amicus curiae, informed the Court of this split. The Chief Justice noted that while some opposing states were small, larger entities like Uttar Pradesh required the Attorney General's intervention to reach a consensus.
Advocate General for Meghalaya stated the proposal was pending with the state Cabinet, while the Telangana Advocate General confirmed an ordinance had been promulgated to raise the age. Conversely, the Haryana Advocate General indicated instructions to let the Court pass an appropriate order. Senior Advocates Vikas Singh and Jaideep Gupta urged the protection of officers' interests, opposing mandatory suitability assessments for those extending service. They highlighted that some eligible officers had already retired, affecting their career progression and financial security.
The Court expressed a desire to close the proceedings on a positive note, with the Chief Justice stressing the value of experienced officers over new incumbents for short tenures. The bench will now await the states' responses before finalizing the judgment, which could mandate the age enhancement across the country.
