The cost of a simple supper of pap and pilchards in South Africa increased by approximately 14 percent in October compared to the same period last year, according to an analysis by AllAfrica. The Pietermaritzburg Economic Justice and Dignity Group calculated that the ingredients for this meal cost an estimated R43.28 in October, up from R37.85 in October 2025. This calculation is based on the group’s Household Affordability Index, which tracks the prices of specific quantities of food items across various retailers.

The primary drivers of this inflationary pressure were onions and canned fish. The amount of onions required for the meal cost R4.79, more than double the R2.35 recorded a year earlier. A single tin of pilchards added R2.30 to the cost compared to the previous year. While the price of maize meal decreased by roughly 59 cents, this saving was insufficient to counterbalance the steep increases in other components. The document excerpt notes that the calculation "excludes oil, seasoning and the cost of cooking," meaning the actual out-of-pocket expense for a prepared meal is higher.

Data from Statistics South Africa, released on 18 November, corroborates the trend of divergent price movements within the food sector. While overall food and non-alcoholic drink prices rose by 1.4 percent year-on-year, canned fish excluding tuna surged by 8.2 percent. Onions saw the most dramatic increase, rising 53.6 percent, while potatoes increased by 14.9 percent. Conversely, maize meal prices fell by 9 percent. The national statistics cover a broader range of products and shops than the local index, but both sources highlight the volatility in vegetable and protein prices.

Supply chain disruptions have contributed to the instability in the canned fish market. In September, retailer Scrolla reported that Lucky Star was facing stock shortages after its owner, Oceana, cited difficulties in sourcing sufficient frozen fish. The October figures reflect the broader impact on the canned-fish category, though it remains unclear how much of the price rise is directly attributable to this specific supply constraint. For families relying on pilchards as an affordable protein source, the marginal savings on maize meal are negligible. The analysis indicates that the price increase for a single tin of pilchards was nearly four times greater than the saving achieved on the maize meal, fundamentally altering the affordability of this staple diet.