The Supreme Court has directed the Uddhav Thackeray faction to provide a clear legal distinction between dissent and defection in the ongoing dispute over the Shiv Sena party. A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana posed these questions to Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, who represents the UBT group. The inquiry centers on whether the actions of the Eknath Shinde faction, which has split from the original party, amount to disqualifiable defection under the 10th Schedule of the Constitution.

According to LiveLaw, the Chief Justice challenged Sibal’s argument that the Shinde group’s intention to exit the alliance could not be classified as mere dissent. The bench noted that while the Shinde faction claims they remain members of Shiv Sena, their grievance is specifically directed at the alliance with the Nationalist Congress Party and the Indian National Congress. "This very line - you are saying amounts to defection," the Chief Justice observed, as reported by LiveLaw, highlighting the core tension in the legal arguments presented.

Justice Bagchi added that the determination of defection versus dissent depends on the nature of the government. She suggested that in a unitary party system, leaving is clearly defection, but in a coalition, a party might legitimately withdraw. Sibal countered that the legislative party is the entity in question, not just the broader political organization. He argued that accepting the Shinde faction's claim of dissent would jeopardize democracy in coalitions, as it would allow members to claim they are still part of the party while opposing its decisions.

The court also addressed the competing claims of both factions to be the legitimate Shiv Sena. Sibal submitted that both groups cannot simultaneously be the party and questioned the status of the Thackeray faction if the Shinde group is recognized as the real party. The hearing involves petitions challenging the Election Commission of India’s decision to allot the official party symbol to the Shinde faction, as well as a plea by UBT member Sunil Prabhu seeking the disqualification of Shinde’s MLAs. The court will resume hearings on Wednesday to hear further arguments on these constitutional matters.