Senior Advocate Dhruv Mehta, representing Eknath Shinde, argued before the Supreme Court that the absence of legislators from a legislative party meeting cannot be grounds for disqualification under the Tenth Schedule of the Constitution. According to LiveLaw, Mehta contended that not attending a meeting does not amount to voluntarily giving up membership of a political party, which is the specific threshold required for disqualification under Article 2(1)(a). The arguments were presented before a bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana.

The legal challenge arises from petitions filed by Sunil Prabhu, a member of the Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray (UBT) faction, against MLAs in the Shinde camp. These petitions allege that the Shinde faction incurred disqualification for failing to attend a legislative party meeting held on June 21, 2022. Mehta questioned this premise, asking how mere non-attendance equates to the voluntary surrender of party membership. He emphasized that the disqualification notices were issued on the letterhead of the Shiv Sena Legislative Office and signed by Prabhu, rather than by a central party authority.

Mehta further disputed the procedural validity of the meeting itself. He stated that a WhatsApp message was sent to Eknath Shinde’s personal assistant at 12:31 PM, just one minute after the meeting had begun at 12:30 PM. He characterized this communication as a simple call for a meeting rather than a formal party whip. Additionally, he noted that the meeting lacked a formal agenda and was described by Prabhu during cross-examination as an attempt at reconciliation because the Shinde faction was initially unreachable. The defense argued that no resolution was passed during this session.

A central point of contention involved an attendance register used as evidence. Mehta described the signatures on this register as fabricated, arguing that the petitioners’ reliance on it was self-contradictory. He pointed out that while the petitioners claimed the members defied the whip by not attending, they simultaneously used the register to show they had signed in. He alleged that signatures of two individuals were forged and inserted, a discrepancy that Prabhu did not deny during his testimony. Mehta submitted that the Speaker had already held the attendance register as unreliable. He concluded his initial submission by asserting that dissent is not defection and does not fall under the purport of the Tenth Schedule. Arguments in the case are scheduled to continue.