The Bombay High Court has set aside a First Information Report registered against Nishkarsh Nimgade, who faced charges for participating in a demonstration in Chandrapur district. The gathering was organized by residents seeking the dismissal of Public Works Department officials after a vehicle overturned on a defective road, resulting in a death. In an order dated October 29, single-judge Justice Mahendra Chandwani, presiding at the Nagpur bench, dismissed the criminal proceedings. According to LiveLaw, the court emphasized that the state cannot utilize penal statutes to suppress democratic agitation.
Justice Chandwani observed that the constitutional guarantee of peaceful assembly under Article 19(1)(b) must not be eroded by vague accusations. The judge noted that the applicant’s sole alleged conduct was demanding the removal of negligent officers. The court stated that prosecution cannot be initiated to suppress democratic agitation, provided participants refrain from violence or property damage. The judge warned that allowing the mindset of unleashing criminal cases against protesters would be detrimental to democracy.
The court reviewed the charge sheet and found no proof that the demonstrators blocked any individual from using the road. Justice Chandwani pointed out that no statements from passersby were recorded to confirm any obstruction. Consequently, the judge ruled that the requirements of Section 126 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita were not met. The order highlighted the absence of evidence identifying who was obstructed, making the unlawful assembly charge unsustainable.
Additionally, the judge clarified that a large gathering cannot be deemed illegal unless it pursues an illegal object as defined in Section 189 of the BNS. Simply assembling to protest road conditions and demand action against contractors does not presume an unlawful assembly. Legal counsel for the applicant included Purushottam Patil, NA Waghmare, Vinay Rathi, and Yash Ghodichor. The State was represented by Additional Public Prosecutor HD Futane. The judgment clarifies the boundary between legitimate protest and criminal conspiracy.
