Two retired employees of Delta Corporation have lost a High Court battle to recover benefits from employee share schemes, after Justice Joel Mambara ruled that their claims had expired decades before they initiated legal proceedings. According to NewZimbabwe, the judge dismissed the lawsuit filed by Claudius Molai and Davison Sithole, upholding a special plea of prescription submitted by Delta Corporation and Delta Trust Fund Limited. The workers sought detailed accounts and payments related to a 1991 share participation trust and a 2008 share empowerment scheme.
The retirees, who joined as general hands during the Rhodesian era, argued that informal workplace systems prevented earlier action. They claimed they rose through the ranks but felt short-changed. However, the court found the company had informed them since 1997 that the first scheme was redeemed, and since 2013 that the second was cashed in. Justice Mambara noted the plaintiffs were awake but did not sue. "That, as will appear, is their difficulty," the judge stated, according to NewZimbabwe.
The judge rejected the argument that workers could not sue because they lacked exact amounts owed. He explained that the right to demand an account is itself a claim subject to prescription. He emphasized that the law does not suspend prescription simply because claimants lack precise figures, warning that doing so would allow every stale claim to be dressed up as a demand for numbers.
Although the retirees lobbied Parliament and the Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission, the court held these actions did not interrupt prescription. Justice Mambara clarified that only service of court process on the debtor can stop the clock. He stated that petitions and letters do not meet legal requirements. The judge calculated that the 1991 claim prescribed in October 2000, and the 2008 claim prescribed in September 2016. By December 2025, the claims were out of time by approximately 25 and 9 years respectively.
While expressing sympathy for two old men who felt short-changed, the judge stressed that statutes of limitation are statutes of repose. He warned that documents are lost, memories fade, and witnesses die, meaning companies cannot keep records indefinitely. The court ordered the retirees to pay the legal costs of Delta Corporation and Delta Trust Fund Limited jointly and severally, effectively laying the dispute to rest.
