The Delhi Police has formally distinguished between traditional journalists and digital content creators in a Supreme Court affidavit, arguing that the latter are not entitled to the protections granted to reporters covering protests. According to MediaNama, the police submitted this position in response to petitions filed by media unions and civil society groups who alleged that officers obstructed and detained journalists during demonstrations against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The affidavit, reported by Bar and Bench, asserts that the court’s October 11 directive, which ensured journalists could discharge their duties without hindrance, was never intended to exempt social media influencers or "unruly elements" from general law enforcement protocols.

The central argument presented by the police is that the "predominant intent" behind an individual's activity should determine their status. The affidavit notes that while many individuals create and commercially exploit reels, this does not automatically elevate them to the status of journalists. The police proposed that officers at protest barricades must judge this intent on the spot to decide if court-ordered protections apply. This stance leaves digital journalists, YouTubers, and freelancers without Press Information Bureau accreditation vulnerable to detention, as these were the groups primarily affected during the October 10 and 11 protests organized by the Cockroach Janta Party.

MediaNama reported that the police denied allegations of obstructing journalists, asking the court to dismiss the petitions. The force cited CCTV footage to refute sexual harassment complaints made by three journalists on October 3, stating that two complainants withdrew their cases and the third did not participate in the inquiry. Regarding specific reporters, the police claimed they merely removed Ryan Thomas of The Caravan for crowd control purposes and denied illegally detaining Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, citing his own account of being driven around and released. The police also questioned whether Shyam Meera Singh was reporting or protesting, noting he shouted slogans.

Justice Joymalya Bagchi indicated during an October 15 hearing that the court would examine whether different categories of media personnel require varying levels of protection. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta previously admitted uncertainty in distinguishing between reel makers and independent journalists. The upcoming Supreme Court ruling will establish the legal framework for how law enforcement treats freelancers and creators at future assemblies across India, potentially setting a precedent for press freedom in the digital age.