A senior academic at the University of the Witwatersrand has warned that generative artificial intelligence is eroding essential computational thinking skills among South African learners. In a commentary published by Daily Maverick, he argues that students and educators are bypassing fundamental analysis for instant AI answers. This reliance threatens the effectiveness of the newly gazetted coding and robotics curriculum, which aims to teach structured problem-solving rather than code generation alone.
The author’s advocacy began in 2017 with the creation of the TANKS app, designed to teach coding without computers. This initiative evolved into the Tangible movement, now active across five continents. The national curricula for Grades R to 9 were gazetted in 2024, but full rollout remains incomplete. While the Fourth Industrial Revolution promised software job growth, employers report that young developers often lack core principles due to overreliance on AI tools for implementation.
A turning point occurred in August when Tangible invited teachers to submit recipes as programming analogies. More than 50% of submissions were AI-generated, revealing that educators were replacing thinking, planning, and solving with simple prompting. This mirrored feedback from colleagues who observed that second-year students viewed prompting as the only solution method. The author emphasizes that computational thinking requires decomposition, abstraction, pattern recognition, and algorithm design. These skills are vital for problem-solving in all life spheres, not just software.
To counter "cognitive surrender," the author cited findings from the World Conference on Computers in Education. Dr Corna Olivier of the University of Pretoria reported that chatbots offering only answers diminish critical thinking. However, she noted that intentionally designed AI can restore cognitive presence. Similarly, Dr Embeth van der Wal found that Tangible lessons improved teachers’ self-efficacy in the foundation phase. The author concludes that while AI has a place, it must enhance, not replace, foundational problem-solving skills. "I choose to write from personal experience and observation," he states, urging educators to secure fundamentals before exposing students to advanced AI tools.
/file/attachments/orphans/Jean-Greyling-think-solve_529354.jpg)