The Supreme Court has ruled that an employee’s history of past misconduct cannot be used to compensate for deficiencies in proving fresh charges, nor can it serve as a standalone instance of new misconduct. According to LiveLaw, the bench comprising Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh clarified that while a service record may inform penalty decisions for independently established offenses, it cannot substitute for evidence in current proceedings. The court made this observation while setting aside the removal from service of Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) constable Sumit Kumar.
Kumar was dismissed in May 2018 after an inquiry officer found him guilty of pressuring the administration through a conditional resignation, circulating a video of his wife, and using relatives to threaten officials. The court found these charges inadequately established. Regarding the video allegation, the judgment noted that a departmental witness stated the footage came from a different mobile number and that Kumar was present at the CISF unit when it was recorded at the hospital. The court held that the mere presence of a video concerning his wife or contact from individuals claiming to be his relatives was insufficient to sustain the charge without direct evidence connecting Kumar to their conduct.
The bench also highlighted procedural failures in the disciplinary process. Kumar was provided Hindi translations of departmental documents only after the prosecution evidence had concluded. Furthermore, his request for a defense assistant was rejected, despite Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, 2001. The court determined that these circumstances deprived him of an effective opportunity to defend himself. The court observed that the submission of a conditional resignation must be viewed in the context of his wife’s serious medical condition and his prior request for leave.
Kumar had initially sought leave in December 2017 to care for his wife, who suffered complications following a miscarriage and surgery. After his request was declined, he submitted a conditional resignation via the grievance portal, citing acute mental stress. He was subsequently granted 12 days' leave, as noted in the document excerpt. The court concluded that his conduct did not warrant the grave penalty of removal. Consequently, the bench directed Kumar’s immediate reinstatement with all consequential benefits and 50% of back wages from the date of his removal until reinstatement, declining to order a fresh inquiry.
