The Punjab and Haryana High Court has dismissed an application filed by a woman seeking to transfer a civil suit against her from Phillaur to Mukerian, ruling that her primary justification relied on a false statement regarding her father’s health. Justice Mandeep Pannu held that the applicant concealed a material fact by claiming her father was sick and bedridden, when in reality he had died years before her marriage. The court determined this misrepresentation disentitled her from the discretionary relief of transfer.
The respondent, the applicant’s brother-in-law, had initiated proceedings for recovery of damages before the Additional Civil Judge in Phillaur. The applicant argued that the case should be moved to Mukerian in District Hoshiarpur, citing her residence in Village Ghaseetpur, approximately 120 kilometers away. She asserted that she lacked independent income and could not travel alone to Phillaur, while also noting that a maintenance petition under Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) was pending in Mukerian between her and her husband.
LiveLaw reported that the respondent opposed the transfer, pointing out that the applicant works as a nurse earning roughly ₹30,000 monthly. He further noted that the First Information Report she filed under Section 498-A of the Indian Penal Code (now Section 85 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita) named only her husband, excluding him from the allegations. The respondent argued that the Mukerian proceedings did not involve him, making the transfer unnecessary and the applicant’s claims of financial or physical hardship unsubstantiated.
The court found the respondent’s version corroborated by a wedding invitation card placed on record, which described the applicant as the daughter of Shakuntla Devi and the late Lakhwinder. Justice Pannu stated that a litigant seeking discretionary relief must approach the court with clean hands and make full disclosure. The judgment noted that the applicant had not only suppressed the truth about her father’s death but also sought advantage based on a factually incorrect assertion. The court concluded that such concealment of material facts directly bearing on the relief sought warrants dismissal. The application was therefore rejected, with Mr. Sunil Agnihotri appearing for the applicant and Ms. Shruti Mandhotra for the respondent.
