The Supreme Court has dismissed a petition challenging the new regulations for rotating reserved seats in Maharashtra’s local bodies, affirming that the state government holds the authority to determine the timing and method of such shifts. A bench comprising Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana observed that no voter or candidate possesses a permanent claim to a specific constituency being reserved for Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidates. The court clarified that the rotation of these seats shall be determined according to the government's discretion, rather than individual entitlement.

The petitioner, represented by Senior Advocate Vipin Sanghi, had initially approached the Bombay High Court to strike down the rule as violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. The High Court had previously dismissed the petition, noting that population percentages had changed since the last census and that the state government was altering constituency areas based on geographical limits. Consequently, the reservation of seats would also change, the High Court observed. The Supreme Court upheld this stance, stating that the petitioners' guesswork regarding future reservations was not grounds to declare the rule arbitrary.

During the hearing, Sanghi argued that the new rule rendered the concept of rotation illusory. He highlighted that his client belonged to a constituency that had never been reserved. Just as the constituency’s turn for reservation arrived, the respondents indicated that the process would start afresh, meaning the constituency might never receive reservation. Sanghi stated, "I am in a constituency where percentage is low," emphasizing that the new cutoff date prevented his area from ever being reserved.

Justice Bagchi responded by clarifying that while the Constitution and the 1961 Rules prescribe rotation, the mechanism is within the state government's jurisdiction. The judge remarked that no one has a right to have their specific constituency reserved, as the cutoff date can always be shifted by the government. The bench noted that the Constitution prescribes proportionate reservation based on population, but the manner and timeframe for rotation are discretionary. The court found no reason to hold that Rule 12 ran counter to the concept of reservation rotation. The dismissal does not prevent the petitioner from making representations for reconsideration of the scheme of rotation as per law.