Babatunde Fashola, the former governor of Lagos State, has formally challenged Atiku Abubakar’s proposal to reinstate fuel subsidies, describing the policy as economically unfeasible. Speaking on Channels Television’s Politics Today program on Tuesday, Fashola demanded that the former vice-president provide a concrete explanation of how his administration would fund the return of subsidies if elected in 2027. According to AllAfrica, Fashola argued that the plan fails to address the practical difficulties inherent in Nigeria’s current energy landscape, particularly the nation's inability to meet crude oil production targets and the persistent security crises in oil-producing regions.

Fashola questioned the source of the crude oil necessary to supply local refineries and sustain a subsidy arrangement. He highlighted that legacy issues, including vandalism and security threats, are preventing the optimization of current production quotas. "No, because they are legacy issues, challenges with security people, vandalism," Fashola stated, according to the report. He insisted that without proof of how the required crude oil would be secured, the proposal relies on unrealistic promises rather than actionable policy. He maintained that his criticism was directed solely at the policy mechanics, not at Abubakar personally, emphasizing that the proposal lacks the necessary groundwork to succeed.

The former minister also pointed out the inconsistency in Abubakar’s political stance, noting that the former vice-president had supported the removal of fuel subsidies during the 2023 presidential campaign. Fashola argued that this reversal raises questions about the sustainability of the new policy and the measures intended to make it viable. He further noted that reinstating subsidies would require legislative action, as lawmakers would need to amend the existing legal framework. He expressed skepticism about whether the National Assembly would support such a move, given the potential strain on public finances.

Drawing on his experience in the previous administration, Fashola warned that subsidy payments have historically constrained funds available to state governments. He recalled that during the period when subsidies were active, states faced significant financial difficulties, often borrowing money to pay salaries. He asked if the country was prepared to return to a system where states receive near-zero returns and face fiscal insolvency. Abubakar announced his plan in August 2026, proposing a temporary, audited arrangement for locally refined petroleum products to lower transportation costs. This contrasts with President Tinubu’s decision to remove subsidies upon his inauguration in May 2023 as part of broader economic reforms.