LiveLaw reviewed Supreme Court jurisprudence on National Press Day, noting that Article 19(1)(a) implicitly guarantees press freedom. The 1962 Sakal Papers case established this, while the 1972 Bennet Coleman judgment condemned laws imposing prohibitive burdens on media circulation. The publication emphasizes that these rulings prevent the state from singling out the press for restrictive regulations.
The review details modern threats, including digital surveillance and strategic litigation. In the 2021 Pegasus case, the court warned that state surveillance chills press freedom and identified source protection as essential. In a 2024 Bloomberg ruling, the court cautioned against casual pre-trial injunctions in defamation suits, highlighting the threat of Strategic Litigation Against Public Participation (SLAPP). The court stated that injunctions should only be granted if content is malicious or palpably false, protecting public debate from being stifled by wealthy entities.
LiveLaw also examines the media’s right to report judicial proceedings. In a 2021 case involving the Election Commission of India, the Supreme Court rejected pleas to stop media reporting on oral court remarks. The court linked this right to the citizens’ right to know, holding that freedom of speech extends to reporting on judicial institutions to ensure accountability. This ensures seamless availability of information about court proceedings.
In a 2025 contempt case against ANI Media, the court set aside an order to delete a Wikipedia page. The ruling asserted that courts cannot instruct the media on what to remove, noting that both judiciary and media are foundational pillars of democracy. The judgment endorsed public discourse and critical commentary as essential democratic functions, stating that both institutions must supplement each other for a liberal constitutional order to survive.
The publication concludes with a recent decision protecting journalist Abhishek Upadhyaya. The Supreme Court quashed a Uttar Pradesh Police notice to X, which sought his social media usage details. The court applied proportionality, finding no justification for tracing private information of a journalist reporting on a donation theft scam. This reinforces protections against state mechanisms aimed at uncovering confidential sources.
