Nature conservation authorities in South Africa’s North West and KwaZulu-Natal provinces are advancing plans to cull thousands of elephants from fenced reserves. Ian Rushworth of Ezemvelo KZN Wildlife has proposed removing 1,220 elephants, while North West Parks advocates for removing 1,000 from Madikme Game Reserve over five years. Officials frame these populations as a catastrophe, asserting lethal action is inevitable due to limited relocation options. However, a Daily Maverick investigation questions whether these measures stem from scientific necessity or the failure to implement existing management strategies.

Critics argue the cull push represents a manufactured emergency. North West Parks agreed in 2022 with Humane World for Animals South Africa to implement immunocontraception. The publication notes that timely execution would have achieved reproductive control in Madikwe by 2026. Despite this missed opportunity, officials have not provided a comprehensive report assessing 34 management scenarios. The report states that a manufactured emergency cannot be used to justify lethal measures when non-lethal alternatives remain unexplored. Officials have remained silent on why the agreed program was abandoned.

South Africa’s National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act and National Norms and Standards for Elephants strictly govern these decisions. Regulations mandate culling be a last resort, permissible only after translocation, contraception, and range management are rejected. Dr Audrey Delsink, senior director at Humane World for Animals SA, stated that barriers to contraception are administrative and policy-related, not technical. She emphasized that authorities must demonstrate, reserve by reserve, what non-lethal measures were implemented and why they were insufficient. The publication highlights that poor accountability has led to weak coordination and transparency.

In KwaZulu-Natal, elephant management plans expired in 2022, with updates still awaiting ministerial consideration. This legal gap raises questions about the validity of culling proposals, as current plans do not authorize lethal removal. Furthermore, a 2026 study of Kruger National Park found no general decline in woody cover, contesting claims of widespread ecological damage. The publication concludes that before irreversible decisions are made, authorities must publish all relevant management plans, ecological data, and approval records to substantiate the necessity of culling.