Constitutional lawyers in Uganda have raised significant legal objections to a proposed power-sharing model known as consociational democracy. The model, championed by Gen Salim Saleh and Prof Ogenga Otunnu, aims to distribute political authority among different ethnic, regional, and religious groups. However, Nile Post reports that legal experts caution that implementing this framework would require far-reaching constitutional reforms that reshape the country’s political structures.
According to the report, a working document bearing signatures of political leaders supports the proposal. Constitutional lawyer Isaac Atukunda stated that such documents hold no legal weight and cannot override the Constitution. He emphasized that under Article 1, all power belongs to the people. "Our Constitution states that power belongs to the people," Atukunda told Nile Post, asserting that political rhetoric cannot substitute for constitutional authority. He argued that any power-sharing arrangement must be created by the Constitution to establish enforceable obligations.
The debate centers on whether Uganda’s current presidential system can accommodate such a shift. While proponents argue sharing power addresses sectarianism, critics question if existing frameworks provide adequate representation. Atukunda noted that a constitutional amendment would be necessary to give the proposal legal authority. This raises questions about the retention of executive authority under a consociational system, particularly regarding the incumbent President.
Constitutional lawyer Galandi Tony Kiire argued that Ugandans must have a direct say in determining governance. He suggested a referendum would be required to seek public opinion. Nile Post notes that while a referendum is not automatically required for every amendment, Article 260 mandates one for changes to entrenched provisions like Article 1. The exact procedure depends on which provisions the proposal seeks to amend. Kiire added that introducing consociational democracy would require a fundamental review to redistribute executive authority.
Legal experts drew parallels with South Africa and Rwanda, which adopted similar arrangements after periods of division. However, they cautioned that Uganda’s context differs significantly. The success of any proposed arrangement, according to Atukunda, depends on constitutional scrutiny and democratic consultation rather than endorsements by influential individuals.
