The Labour Court in Gqeberha has rejected Aspen Pharmacare’s request to challenge a judgment that mandates the reinstatement of former worker Roderick Munnick. The decision, delivered on 11 November 2026, ends a legal struggle spanning ten years. Judge Molatelo Robert Makhura ruled that the pharmaceutical firm did not prove another court would likely reach a different verdict or that compelling reasons justified an appeal. According to Daily Maverick, the application was dismissed because it failed to meet the necessary legal standards.

Aspen Pharmacare had sought to appeal on thirteen grounds, contesting the initial determination that Munnick was innocent of the misconduct leading to his firing. The company alleged he encouraged staff to join an illegal protest in May 2016. He was terminated on 8 September 2016. In September 2026, however, Judge Makhura found no proof that Munnick urged participation in the strike and declared the dismissal substantively unfair. The judge also observed that the penalty was excessive even if guilt had been proven, noting inconsistent disciplinary practices by the employer.

Munnick, lacking formal legal education, managed much of this complex litigation independently after his initial lawyers withdrew. He described to Daily Maverick in October the intense effort required to prepare his case, stating he studied legal documents from noon until 4am for months. "I’m talking from June until the night before the hearing," he said, highlighting the grueling nature of his self-education in labour law. The court substituted the arbitration award with an order declaring the dismissal unfair and directing retrospective reinstatement along with back pay for specified periods.

The consequences of the decade-long dispute have been severe for Munnick. He told Daily Maverick that the unfair dismissal had a devastating impact on his life, leading to eviction during the pandemic and forcing him to live in a small room behind his mother’s home. He stated that the situation cost him his family and the lifestyle he had built, including his ability to support his children and local soup kitchens. Aspen spokesperson Shauneen Beukes declined to comment on the ruling on 20 November 2026, stating the company does not discuss internal or employee-related matters through the media.