Darius Khambata, a former trustee of the Tata Trusts, has issued a formal rebuttal to vice chairmen Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh. In a four-page letter reviewed by PTI, Khambata characterizes the vice chairmen’s recent support for a public listing as a "volte-face" that contradicts their positions in March 2024, May 2025, and July 2025. He argues that this sudden shift lacks justification and misrepresents the core principles of the Tata Group’s governance structure. The dispute highlights deep fractures within the conglomerate’s leadership regarding its future corporate strategy.
Khambata, a senior lawyer, emphasizes that the essence of the "Tata Model" lies in the control of Tata Sons by the Tata Trusts, a collection of non-profit organizations. These trusts collectively own two-thirds of the conglomerate’s holding company. "As I have consistently said, all Trustees are equal," Khambata wrote, rejecting the vice chairmen’s characterization of his defense as a protection of the "present leadership" of the Trusts. He asserts that every trustee has a fiduciary duty to protect Tata Sons, which serves as the primary asset of the Trusts. He argues that the debate over listing merits should be conducted within Trust meetings rather than through media correspondence.
The dispute follows a recent communication from a senior Reserve Bank of India (RBI) official to Tata Sons. This correspondence explicitly mentioned the need for the company to list and offered guidance on the process. The RBI letter was triggered by a communication from Tata Sons dated October 6, which informed the central bank of deliberations held at the board meeting on September 17. In that letter, Tata Sons stated it would "ensure full compliance" with RBI regulations on Non-Banking Financial Company Upper Layer entities. Khambata notes that the vice chairmen’s November 13 letter failed to explain their change in stance on listing.
Khambata also addressed personal accusations made against him, denying claims that he attempted to oust Srinivasan as a trustee to alter the Tata Trusts’ constitution. He expressed continued satisfaction with the performance of Tata Sons chairman N. Chandrasekaran but criticized the September 17 board meeting. A majority approved Chandrasekaran’s reappointment despite Noel Tata’s minority opposition. Khambata described that day as one of "infamy," particularly because Srinivasan broke ranks to vote with the majority of Tata Sons directors. He concluded that his criticism of the board’s actions has led to personal attacks, stating his conscience is clear.
