On Tuesday, the Supreme Court overturned a Bombay High Court order that had validated the dismissal of an Assistant Teacher, declaring the disciplinary process legally invalid due to inherent bias. Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan restored a lower tribunal’s earlier verdict that had reinstated the employee with full back wages. The Court also instructed the Education Officer to explore placing the teacher in another fully government-aided school under specific state regulations, as reported by LiveLaw.

The dispute began when the school secretary, Rajesh Masurkar, complained that the teacher was excluded from salary grants. The management formed an inquiry panel under Rule 36 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools Rules. Prakash Masurkar, the secretary’s brother, chaired this committee. The secretary served as the prosecutor and main witness, while his brother presided over the proceedings that led to the teacher’s termination.

LiveLaw reported that the Court emphasized that justice requires impartiality and that the appearance of bias is as damaging as proven prejudice. The bench described the situation as a "total familial capture" of the inquiry process. It noted that when one family controls the roles of accuser, witness, and judge, the essential separation of functions in a fair hearing disappears. The Court rejected claims that the teacher had waived her rights, noting her objections were formally recorded during the inquiry.

The bench clarified that proving actual bias is not required. Instead, the test is whether a reasonable person would perceive a "real possibility of bias." Citing previous legal precedents, the Court stated that close kinship disqualifies individuals from serving on such panels if it creates reasonable apprehension. The judgment held that procedural steps like cross-examination cannot fix a fundamental defect in the decision-making structure. Consequently, the High Court’s validation of the dismissal was set aside, and the reinstatement order was restored.