The Jharkhand High Court has upheld the dismissal of a husband’s petition for divorce, ruling that he failed to provide sufficient evidence that his wife was aware of a court decree for restitution of conjugal rights or that she intended to permanently end their marriage. A Division Bench comprising Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Akhil Kumar agreed with the Family Court’s earlier decision to reject the husband’s claim for dissolution of marriage under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

According to LiveLaw, the legal dispute originated from a marriage solemnised in Ranchi on May 11, 1995, which produced two sons. The husband alleged that marital discord began in 2013 when his wife insisted he relocate to Bhuli in Dhanbad to live with her retired parents. He claimed she left the matrimonial home in Ranchi on April 13, 2013, taking the children to her parental residence and refusing to return despite his efforts to reconcile.

Following these events, the husband filed a petition under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act seeking restitution of conjugal rights. LiveLaw reported that the Family Court allowed this petition ex-parte on November 11, 2016. The husband subsequently argued that his wife’s failure to comply with this decree justified a divorce under Section 13(1A)(ii), which permits dissolution if conjugal life has not been resumed for over a year after such a decree.

However, the High Court observed that the husband had not produced cogent evidence proving his wife knew about the ex-parte order. The Bench noted that mere separation does not constitute desertion; the petitioner must also prove animus deserendi, or the specific intention to permanently terminate cohabitation. LiveLaw quoted the court’s observation that the wife’s separate residence was a consequence of prevailing circumstances rather than an intent to forsake the relationship, citing her categorical assertion of willingness to reside with her husband.

The court found that the materials on record did not disclose the requisite intention to desert on the part of the respondent. Consequently, the Bench concluded that the essential ingredients for desertion remained unproved. The judgment reinforces the legal standard that a spouse seeking divorce on these grounds must establish both knowledge of the restitution decree and a deliberate intent to abandon the matrimonial bond, neither of which was satisfied in this case.