The Allahabad High Court has ruled that a father’s obligation to fund his child’s education cannot be exploited as a mechanism for financial oppression. In a decision delivered on Saturday, the bench comprising Justice Prakash Padia and Justice Indrajeet Shukla reduced the father’s monthly maintenance liability from Rs 15,000 to Rs 12,000. The court held that while fathers must provide education commensurate with their means, the socio-economic status of both parents must be weighed when adjudicating expenses under Section 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

According to LiveLaw, the dispute arose from a matrimonial petition filed by the husband in May 2022, eight years after their marriage. The wife sought Rs 35,000 monthly for their daughter, including Rs 56,000 for admission fees at a private school in Greater Noida. The husband contested this, noting he earned Rs 37,504 monthly as an inter-college clerk, supported ailing parents, and maintained an unemployed brother. He argued the wife, earning Rs 60,000 as a central school clerk, had shifted the child from a free central school to a private institution without demonstrating that the previous school was inadequate.

The trial court had initially assigned Rs 15,000 to the father and Rs 20,000 to the mother. The High Court found this allocation unreasonable given the child was previously receiving free education. The bench stated that the mother’s choice to switch schools without material proof of deficiency in the former institution did not justify the higher claim. The court directed the father to pay Rs 12,000 monthly, with arrears to be cleared within two months.

The judgment also clarified that the father’s liability does not depend on custody transfer. Rejecting the husband’s argument that his obligation arises only upon gaining custody, the court cited the Supreme Court’s ruling in Ms. Githa Hariharan v. Reserve Bank of India. It affirmed that mothers can act as natural guardians and that maintaining children is a joint parental duty. The court emphasized that gender-based preferences in guardianship would violate Article 15(3) of the Constitution. The appeal was partly allowed, adjusting the financial burden to reflect the actual educational needs and the father’s economic reality.