The Madhya Pradesh High Court has determined that possessing papers showing an ancestor’s tribal identity does not grant an automatic right to be recognized as a Scheduled Tribe member. Justice Milind Ramesh Phadke delivered this ruling while dismissing a petition filed by individuals seeking certificates for the Mogia Tribe. According to LiveLaw, the court emphasized that family documents must be evaluated alongside other relevant circumstances under applicable legal provisions.
The petitioners had challenged an order dated August 21, 2012, issued by the High Power Scrutiny Committee, which rejected their claim for certificate issuance. Their legal counsel, Advocate Divakar Vyas, argued that the Mogia Tribe is officially listed as a Scheduled Tribe in the state. The counsel submitted that the family had previously applied for certificates, providing documentary evidence that included a caste certificate issued in the name of their father. They further contended that the committee’s earlier order of October 13, 2008, was cryptic and passed without granting the petitioners an opportunity to be heard.
Representing the state, Government Advocate Dharmendra Nayak argued that the competent scrutiny committee had examined the claims using its statutory and administrative authority. The state’s counsel maintained that the issuance of a certificate to one family member is insufficient proof of tribal status for others. The court agreed with this position, noting that the petitioners failed to demonstrate any illegality, procedural infirmity, or jurisdictional error in the committee’s decision. The bench observed that documents showing the tribal status of a family member alone are not sufficient for recognition.
Relying on the Supreme Court precedent in Kumari Madhuri Patil vs Addl. Commissioner, Tribal Development, the bench reiterated that the scrutiny committee must undertake a fresh consideration of the claim. The committee is required to arrive at its own conclusion based on the material available rather than relying solely on ancestral certificates. The court noted that the petitioners failed to show that the impugned order suffered from any infirmity. Consequently, the petition was dismissed, upholding the rejection of the Scheduled Tribe certificates for the Mogia Tribe claimants.
