The Calcutta High Court has ruled that statutory provident fund documentation holds greater weight than an employer's assertion that an employee's service history is fabricated. LiveLaw reports that the court upheld a labour tribunal decision in favour of Gouri Nath Banerjee, a former worker at Eastern Coalfields Limited. The tribunal had previously ordered the company to reinstate Banerjee and pay back wages, a decision the company sought to overturn by alleging his appointment papers were forged.

Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul) observed that independent records from the Coal Mines Provident Fund Office confirmed Banerjee’s appointment date at Ajoy-II Colliery as March 22, 1982. The judge stated that minor administrative variations in account numbers or external data generation could not be treated as fraudulent acts by the employee. The court emphasized that Banerjee had no authority over these statutory records, which served as the primary evidence for the tribunal’s findings regarding his employment timeline.

Eastern Coalfields Limited argued that Banerjee secured his 1984 position at Nakrakonda Colliery using false transfer orders and last pay certificates. The company claimed he never worked at Ajoy-II Colliery and that the supporting documents were invalid. Following an internal inquiry, the company terminated Banerjee’s employment in 1996. The petitioners highlighted discrepancies in the provident fund account numbers and differences in the employee’s father’s name as proof of fraud, noting that original appointment documents were not produced.

The High Court rejected these arguments, noting that the tribunal had found no actual discrepancies in the provident fund records themselves. The court pointed out that Banerjee had worked at Nakrakonda Colliery for roughly ten years and received two promotions, which corroborated his service history. Additionally, the court noted that an Eastern Coalfields witness admitted no verification of the transfer order was conducted at the time of hiring.

The Central Government Industrial Tribunal in Asansol had directed the company to treat Banerjee as a continuing employee from the date of dismissal until superannuation, including back wages. The High Court dismissed the writ petition on October 12, 2026, reinforcing that independent statutory records cannot be dismissed due to minor administrative inconsistencies raised by the employer.