The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh at Srinagar has modified an order issued by the Jammu and Kashmir Special Tribunal, ruling that a failure by municipal authorities to decide on building permission objections within a stipulated timeframe does not automatically cancel the permission. LiveLaw reported that Justice Sanjay Dhar held the order keeping the permission in abeyance was a temporary measure that could not remain in force in perpetuity. The court modified the tribunal’s direction, which had stated that default would lead to deemed permission for the private respondent.
The dispute originated from litigation between the inhabitants of Syedabad Kupwara and a private respondent regarding construction on land belonging to a Masjid in Kupwara. The municipal authorities had previously granted permission for the construction of a commercial building. This permission was challenged by the petitioners through a revision petition before the Jammu and Kashmir Special Tribunal in Srinagar, which dismissed the petition on October 20, 2022. Subsequently, the municipal authorities issued an order on October 8, 2022, keeping the building permission in abeyance to consider complaints from the petitioners and other objectors.
The private respondent challenged the abeyance order before the Special Tribunal, which issued an order on September 8, 2025. The tribunal directed the municipal authorities to take a final decision within thirty days, stating that failure to do so would result in the abeyance order being deemed cancelled and the private respondent being free to proceed with construction. LiveLaw reported that the High Court found merit in the petitioners' grievance regarding this specific direction. Justice Dhar observed that the petitioner was particularly aggrieved by the provision for deemed permission in favor of the respondent upon default.
The court clarified that the validity of the abeyance order could only be stretched until the municipal authorities decided on the objections. However, the High Court modified the tribunal’s order to the extent that default by the municipal authorities would not lead to the automatic cancellation of the abeyance order. The court directed the authorities to decide the issue within the thirty-day period starting from the date of the judgment. It remained open for both the petitioners and the private respondent to make additional representations and produce documents before the officials while the final decision was being taken. The writ petition and all connected applications were disposed of accordingly.
