The Telangana High Court has dismissed a legal challenge regarding the acquisition of private land for the Kalwakurthy bypass on National Highway 167K, establishing a clear boundary on judicial intervention in infrastructure planning. According to LiveLaw, the Division Bench comprising Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Suddala Chalapathi Rao ruled that judicial review in such matters is strictly limited. The court observed that it is not equipped to evaluate the viability or feasibility of specific projects, nor can it determine whether a particular road alignment serves the broader public interest. Interference by the judiciary is warranted only in exceptional circumstances where a violation of statutory mandates or mala fides is established.
The petitioner, a landowner in Nagarkurnool District, had contested the acquisition of his one-acre plot. He argued that the authorities deviated from the final map by changing the bypass commencement point from chainage 76/400 to 76/100, a change that necessitated the seizure of his land. The appellant further claimed that his objections, filed in October 2022, were ignored and that the subsequent Section 3D notification under the National Highways Act, 1956, was therefore illegal. He contended that had the original alignment been maintained, his property would not have been required for the project.
In its response, the state authorities explained that the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways approved a third alignment option, which begins at chainage 76/100. The government stated that this decision was communicated to the petitioner through an RTI reply in 2022. LiveLaw reported that the Revenue Divisional Officer, acting as the competent authority, considered the petitioner's objections and rejected them via endorsements dated October and December 2022. The notification was published in Namasthe Telangana on April 13, 2023, followed by an award for land acquisition on September 20, 2023.
The court found no merit in the appellant's claims, noting that the objections were duly processed and rejected by the competent authority. The bench highlighted that the state had provided specific explanations regarding the alignment options and the consideration of grievances. Additionally, the counsel for the state informed the court that the bypass construction was 95% complete, though public use was delayed due to a missing 200-metre stretch. The court concluded that the petitioner failed to demonstrate any grounds for interference with the Single Judge’s order, dismissing the writ appeal as devoid of merits.
