Justice James Omotosho of the Federal High Court in Abuja rejected an Economic and Financial Crimes Commission request to freeze funds linked to Jedidiah Cement Industry Ltd. According to Nairametrics, the judge ruled on November 10 that the application amounted to a gross abuse of court process. The regulator had sought to secure assets pending an investigation into an alleged N1.7 billion fraud involving false pretences.
The EFCC argued that the cement company and its associates diverted money meant for foreign currency purchases to buy luxury vehicles and properties. However, Omotosho noted the commission was aware of a separate criminal suit, Charge No. FHC/ABJ/CR/192/2021, where the defendant had already been acquitted regarding the same account. The judge stated that filing a new forfeiture application while the earlier case was pending constituted forum shopping and an attempt to harass the defendant rather than pursue legitimate justice.
In Zimbabwe, the High Court in Harare dismissed an application by Ruth Gwashavanhu to remove 11 people from a 238-hectare farm at Fairview Estate in Goromonzi. Justice Priscilla Munangati-Manongwa ruled that the matter involved competing beneficiaries from different stages of the national land reform programme. NewZimbabwe reported that the judge found the dispute required a full evidential inquiry rather than a summary eviction order.
Gwashavanhu held an A2 Model Settlement Permit issued by the Ministry of Lands, which she argued gave her lawful occupancy rights. The respondents, however, claimed they had been allocated plots under the A1 scheme years earlier and relied on a 2004 consent order allowing them to remain until properly resettled. The judge emphasized that a valid permit does not automatically supersede earlier allocations or prove that the specific land in question was covered by the newer instrument.
Munangati-Manongwa warned that the case highlighted persistent tenure anxiety caused by successive land allocations. She stated that neither long occupation nor a later permit conclusively settled the boundary and rights disputes. The court declined to invalidate Gwashavanhu’s permit or establish superior rights for the occupants, leaving the resolution of these competing claims to proceedings capable of receiving necessary evidence.
Both rulings demonstrate judicial reluctance to enforce administrative or regulatory actions when procedural history and overlapping claims remain unresolved. The Nigerian court prioritized procedural integrity in criminal investigations, while the Zimbabwean court emphasized the need for certainty in land rights amidst complex reform legacies.
