United Nations member states have agreed to a two-year timeline to develop an international instrument regulating lethal autonomous weapons systems. The decision was reached late Saturday after five days of intense negotiations in Geneva that extended into overtime. While the agreement establishes a framework for future talks, it stops short of committing to legally binding rules. This outcome has drawn sharp criticism from humanitarian groups and many participating nations.
The conference, held under the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, saw approximately 100 countries support the need for regulation. However, significant arms-producing nations, including the United States, Russia, and Israel, opposed measures that would restrict their development of such technologies. The requirement for full consensus among the 128 parties to the convention meant that the final text was diluted. Conference president Julien Thoni stated that the process would now focus on determining which weapons should be forbidden under international humanitarian law.
Izumi Nakamitsu, the UN high representative for disarmament affairs, described the outcome as a significant achievement. She acknowledged the compressed timeframe, noting that completing a strong instrument within two years would require extensive negotiations. Nakamitsu emphasized that the path to a legally binding instrument remains open. She warned that the consequences of failing to establish such rules are clear, particularly as the technology advances rapidly in active conflicts like Ukraine and Sudan.
Advocacy organizations expressed profound disappointment with the weakened mandate. Stop Killer Robots, a global coalition, described the outcome as a watered-down failure. Beatrice Fihn of Lex International criticized the decision as pushing the problem down the road. Verity Coyle of Human Rights Watch argued that the outcome fails to provide the urgent action needed. Rain Liivoja, a security law expert, remarked that the consensus merely makes everyone equally unhappy, with many experts warning that a treaty by 2028 is unlikely.
