Former Supreme Court Judge Justice V Gopala Gowda has launched a severe critique of the Election Commission of India (ECI), alleging that the body has illegally removed 13 crore voters from electoral rolls to assist a political party in gaining power. Speaking at an event in Bhubaneswar on November 18, Gowda described the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise as an unconstitutional attack on national sovereignty. According to LiveLaw, the former judge asserted that adult franchise is a fundamental constitutional right and that the people, rather than institutions like the Supreme Court or the ECI, hold supreme authority in a democracy.

Gowda’s comments followed an investigative report by The Indian Express published on September 23, which highlighted objections raised by two ECI members regarding various SIR moves. The former judge argued that the ECI had obtained the Supreme Court’s May 27 judgment approving the SIR by misrepresenting vital aspects of the revision process. He stated that the subsequent conduct of the Chief Election Commissioner, including issuing press statements and filing affidavits, lent credence to these allegations. Gowda warned that the SIR must not become a mechanism for political parties to bundle Form 7 applications to delete voters in bulk.

In a separate development concerning the same revision process, the Supreme Court on Thursday directed the ECI and the Delhi Chief Electoral Officer to verify complaints of fraudulent voter deletions in the Mustafabad constituency. The bench, comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana, disposed of a writ petition filed by Congress leader Ali Mehdi without expressing an opinion on the merits of the allegations. The court ordered the authorities to take necessary remedial steps if the claims of fraud are substantiated.

The petition relied on reports indicating that most Booth Level Agents (BLAs) whose names appeared on Form 7 applications denied signing them. Mehdi’s counsel submitted that out of 37 Form 7s filed in the constituency, 36 were false, and 28 electors targeted for deletion were still alive and residing at their listed addresses. Justice Bagchi noted that while the ECI can blacklist BLAs for fraudulent applications, it has no direct control over them as they are agents of political parties. The court advised the petitioner to approach a magistrate for FIR registration, noting that representations had already been made to the police, ECI, and CEO.