The Board of Trustees at The Fountain of Life Church in Lagos has withdrawn recognition of Pastor Jimmy Odukoya as its senior pastor. The announcement was made in a statement on Tuesday, November 17, following a review of a video recording and the church’s constitution. According to Punch, the board stated that late founder Taiwo Odukoya had designated another individual to succeed him. This detail was not apparent when Jimmy assumed leadership after his father’s death in August 2023.

The controversy centers on a video reportedly recorded in December 2021 at Jimmy Odukoya’s request. In the recording, the late founder stated his preference for Pastor Kunle Areogun to take over spiritual leadership. "Please, the next pastor of the church should be Kunle Areogun," Taiwo Odukoya said, according to Punch. The founder assigned Jimmy the roles of administrative assistant and head of the youth church. The video was witnessed by Jimmy’s elder brother, Pastor John Odukoya, and was only presented to the trustees after they initially sought information about succession plans.

The trustees also cited concerns regarding Jimmy Odukoya’s recent remarriage and the public blessing of the union. They described these developments as contrary to the church’s teachings and the standards expected of its spiritual leadership. They alleged that the situation caused distress among members and brought the church into public controversy. The board emphasized that it had sought a peaceful resolution through meetings with respected religious leaders but claimed Jimmy rejected the advice offered during the reconciliation process. The Fountain of Life Church itself has rejected the removal, describing it as constitutionally invalid and maintaining that Jimmy remains the duly appointed senior pastor.

Following the decision to remove Jimmy Odukoya, the trustees appointed Pastor Rotimi Okpaise as the interim spiritual and administrative leader. Okpaise, a retired actuary with over 30 years of experience in insurance and consultancy, will oversee the church’s affairs pending consultations to establish a substantive leadership structure. Punch reported that Okpaise served as a partner at Ernst & Young and led the insurance sector practice across West Africa. The appointment underscores the deepening split within the ministry, with two groups now making competing claims over authority and governance. The church’s website and sermon archives confirm that Kunle Areogun has been a longstanding pastor at the Ilupeju headquarters, preaching regularly since at least 2017.