The Allahabad High Court has dismissed an appeal filed by the paternal grandparents of an eight-year-old boy, upholding a lower court order that granted custody of the child to his mother. The division bench, comprising Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Kshitij Shailendra, ruled that the grandparents' superior financial position does not constitute a valid ground for depriving the mother of custody. According to LiveLaw, the court observed that the appellants could instead provide financial assistance to the mother to ensure the child's upbringing rather than seeking custody based on economic disparity.
The dispute originated from a habeas corpus petition filed by the mother, identified in court documents as respondent no. 7, following the death of her husband. She alleged that after her husband died by suicide in Ghaziabad on November 28, 2025, her in-laws forcibly detained their minor son. The mother stated that she reached Ghaziabad the following day with her parents and both children for the cremation, after which the grandparents retained the boy. Having received no relief from police authorities, she approached the High Court to secure her son's return.
The Single Judge, who passed the initial order on May 27, 2026, had evaluated affidavits from both sides regarding income, assets, and proposed care arrangements. The judge directed that custody be handed over to the mother, citing the child's tender age, continuity of care, and the emotional security provided by the mother. The High Court noted that the younger daughter, aged four, had remained with the mother throughout, while only the son had been detained by the grandparents since the father's death.
In their appeal, the grandparents contended that the child's welfare lay with them due to the mother's limited income of approximately Rs. 20,000 per month from tuition fees. They argued that the lower court had prioritized maternal status over financial stability. The High Court, however, found that the Single Judge had considered significant factors including criminal cases lodged between the parties, the suicide, and provisions under Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956. The bench refused to interfere with the well-structured order, noting that the grandparents had not placed records of any separate proceedings under the Guardians and Wards Act before the court. The court allowed the grandparents to seek appropriate remedies in the district court regarding visitation rights.
