Authorities in Cape Town have faced intense scrutiny following the capture of the Waterfall baboon troop in Simon’s Town, with critics arguing that the moral justification provided arrived only after the operation was complete. According to Daily Maverick, the Joint Task Team, which includes CapeNature and the City of Cape Town, moved 45 baboons to the Urban Wildlife Centre at Kogelfontein between Friday and Saturday. The publication reports that one old female was euthanised after being found gravely ill, while the remaining 44 were placed in an electrified enclosure for lifelong captivity. One female escaped capture entirely.

The operation began on Friday morning, and by Sunday, more than 100 people had gathered in silent protest beside the enclosure. In response, the Joint Task Team issued a statement claiming the relocation was a "very last resort" and an alternative to culling. The statement asserted that the move would improve the welfare of the baboons, while admitting that placing wildlife into captivity is "always undesirable". Daily Maverick notes that while this ethical framing is welcome, its timing and internal consistency are deeply problematic.

The publication argues that the ethical language used in the Sunday statement contradicts the Baboon Management Action Plan itself. Section 4.3 of the plan, added after public comment closed, focuses exclusively on justifying the killing of baboons. It explicitly states that ethical issues associated with translocations and sanctuaries were not considered. Consequently, the capture proceeded without any formal ethical assessment. The statement presents lifelong captivity as the lesser of two evils, yet the plan’s own appendix on sanctuaries judges captivity to be the greater harm, stating it is not based on conservation principles.

Daily Maverick further contends that the claim of being a "last resort" is flawed because other interventions were evaluated but not tried. For instance, a baboon-proof fence along the firebreak above Simon’s Town, which a private donor offered to fund, was declined by authorities who instead spent R10-million on the Kogelfontein facility. The publication argues that ethics must be a process of deliberation before action, not a justification after the fact. It warns that without a proper moral weighing of options, the current approach normalizes lifelong captivity for future troops, including the Seaforth troop, which is already named for removal.