The Supreme Court has dismissed an appeal by the Kerala government, clarifying that automatic vesting of private forests under the 1971 Act applies exclusively to lands satisfying the statutory definition of a private forest. According to LiveLaw, a bench comprising Justice PS Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe held that while ownership transfers by operation of law from May 10, 1971, it does not extend to land failing Section 2(f) criteria. The court affirmed that vesting does not depend on boundary demarcation or notifications under Rule 2A, provided the land is legally classified as a private forest. The judgment upheld concurrent findings by the Forest Tribunal and High Court that 12 acres at Nilambur Amsom in Edakkara Village, Malappuram, did not qualify as a private forest and thus did not vest in the state.
The dispute involved respondents claiming their father leased the land in 1960 and cultivated it until 1976. After Forest Department officials obstructed operations in 1988, the respondents sought a declaration that the land was not a private forest. The Forest Tribunal initially dismissed the application in 1991 but ruled on remand in 2001 that the land was not a private forest. The tribunal found no evidence the land was governed by the Madras Preservation of Private Forests Act, 1949, noting Range Officers admitted there were no documents establishing such governance. A commissioner’s report indicated bamboo clusters less than 10 years old and four wells, leading to the conclusion that the land was neither wooded nor an enclave on the appointed day. The High Court affirmed this in 2008, stating automatic vesting only applies if the land is a private forest.
During proceedings, the Kerala government attempted to introduce a 1990 notification and a 1900 notification under the Madras Forest Act, 1882. The bench rejected the application to place the 1990 notification on record, observing that late production exhibited a lack of due diligence. The court noted that a party cannot adduce evidence to fill lacunae or set up a new case. Regarding the 1900 notification, the court found it lacked a description by which the land could be identified or inferred to be contiguous to the subject land. The state’s own affidavit indicated the private forest pertained to the Kariam Muriam block, with no material showing it was contiguous to the disputed land.
